Posted by Lou Pilder on March 25, 2015, at 5:46:59
In reply to Re: The Hsiung-Pilder discussion, posted by Dr. Bob on March 24, 2015, at 22:38:58
> > Be advised, my friend, that I do not accept any reason in your thinking to justify leaving posts where they are originally posted that could foster hatred toward the Jews here to be seen as supportive and in your thinking will be good for this community as a whole. You say that you only take responsibility for posts that you author. Your posts here that attempt to justify leaving anti-Semitism to be seen as supportive where those posts are originally posted, is what you could take responsibility for, for you have rejected the opportunity that has been given to you to remediate and clarify that you do not consider the statements to be supportive. And by this rejection of yours to post a disclaimer to those statements, in my thinking you are saying that you will take responsibility for any injuries or deaths or suicides that arise out of readers seeing that you are allowing hatred toward the Jews to be seen as supportive where those posts are originally posted, and worse, you are rejecting the opportunity to post a disclaimer to show otherwise.
> 1. The only messages I take responsibility for are my own, but I do also take responsibility for my administrative decisions.
> 2. I see the risk of deaths or suicides arising from those posts as low, so I can accept it. Like I can accept the risk of deaths or suicides arising from your posts.
> 3. I'm pleased you referred to me as your friend.
There could be harm to come to me from here and harm could come to all Jews because the anti-Semitic statements being allowed by you and your deputies of record to be seen as civil and supportive, and worse, that by them being allowed to be seen as such, that it will be good in your thinking for this community as a whole to be seen that way. There is no denying by you of this harm to come from here to me and other Jews. And the fact that you refuse to honor your own rules here that could stop the hatred toward the Jews posted here as being able to be thought to be civil and supportive by you and your deputies of record, that you say you will take responsibility for because it is a conscious administrative decision by you to ignore my pleas to post a repudiation to the anti-Semitism being allowed here to be seen as being ratified by you and your deputies of record. But worse, the hate could be created and developed by you and your deputies of record and all the members that could be seen as being in concert with you here, by you rejecting the opportunity to post that the anti-Semitic statements are not supportive where they are originally posted. This is different than simple negligence. This is a policy of discrimination and abuse of your power to allow hatred toward the Jews to be fostered here as supportive. since it is your policy, then since your policy denies the equal protection of your rules to the Jews, then those that understand how anti-Semitism is created and developed by an administration could see your policy as an anti-Semitic policy because it is against the Jews,and hence this site to be an anti-Semitic site, just as if a city government denied the equal protection of its laws to Jews, it could be deemed to be an anti-Semitic city.
And to say that the harm that could come to me and other Jews by anti-Semitism being allowed to be posted here with impunity, and allow it to continue, could lead a subset of jurists to consider your actions, or inactions, to be malicious.
Here is a link that discusses this in some respect. But it is much more than that. For you now say that the harm that could come to me and Jews by you refusing to apply your own rules to sanction those statements is a low probability, that could show to a subset of readers to constitute contempt toward Jews here, as not being worthy to have hatred that is posted against them here to be sanctioned by you and your team of deputies as to be seen that the harm that could come to me and the Jews is unworthy to have your own rules apply to me and other Jews.
As you being a psychiatrist and a teacher, that is a powerful influence to children and adults to create and develop anti-Semitic hate from here. And the flames that produce the embers of hate to be carried by the winds of the internet into the minds of vulnerable readers from here, could erupt into violence toward Jews without you knowing it. But you allow the fire of hate to burn from here continually by allowing anti-Semitic hate to be seen as supportive by you.
Not likely? By what authority do you use, if any, to make such a claim?