![[dr. bob]](/dr-bob-sm.gif)
Dr. Bob is Robert Hsiung, MD,
bob@dr-bob.orgShown: posts 20 to 44 of 44. Go back in thread:
Posted by SLS on January 2, 2001, at 10:34:27
In reply to Re: Scott- Lamotrigine's AD/dopaminergic action, posted by AndrewB on January 2, 2001, at 1:31:43
Hi Andrew.
You have invited quite a questions regarding your "factoids" :-)> Antidepressants (when effective) cause upregulation of the D2/(D3?) receptors in the shell of the nucleus accumbums (a site associated with mood and anxiety)
All antidepressants, all of the time when they do work?
> and downregulation of the NMDA receptors.
Where can I find some material regarding this?
> NMDA is one of the three glutaminergic receptors subtypes along with the AMPA and Kainate receptors.
> Possibly NMDA antagonism is the route by which antidepressants upregulate the D2/D3 receptors.
Through what mechanisms?
> NMDA antagonists can exhibit antidepressant effects.
Ketamine? Which others?
> Abnormal glutaminergic transmission, especially involving the NMDA receptor, is associated with depression.
> Abnormal glutaminergic transmission is associated with bipolar disorder.
Is there something on Medline I could look at. To what degree is this considered to be putative?
> Combined AMPA and Kainate receptors antagonists are potent anticonvulsants.
> AMPA and NMDA receptor antagonists can act synergistically to provide robust anticonvulsant action at doses that do not produce behavioral side effects.
> (It seems that glutamate receptor antagonists hold great promise for side effect free control of bipolar cycling.)
> The partial NMDA antagonist Memantine (available from overseas) increases the effectiveness of Depakote for bipolar disorder without extra side effects.
> (I wonder if Memantine may also increase the effectiveness of Lamotrigine. One study showed that Lamotrigine increased the mood elevating effects of ketamine, a total NMDA antagonist, and decreased its cognitive impairment.)
> In sum, Lamotrigine’s effectiveness in controlling cycling may well involve actions on all the glutamate receptors, while its mood effects may be primarily dopaminergic mediated through the NMDA receptors.
This sounds pretty good. I hadn't realized the extent to which glutamatergic function was a focus in the research of depressive disorders.
I read something that indicated that unlike phenytoin and gabapentin, lamotrigine appeared to act presynaptically to reduce electrically-evoked action potentials measured along cortico-striatal excitatory neurons, but had no effect upon the magnitude of depolarization when glutamate was applied directly, as did the former two. I don't yet know how to interpret this, except that it supports the notion that lamotrigine acts, in part, via glutamate-release inhibition. I think recall reading that glutamate, and perhaps aspartate, serve to modulate the reuptake of dopamine. Therefore, a reduction in the amount of glutamate rather than a muting of postsynaptic stimulation to glutamate would allow lamotrigine to be uniquely dopaminergic.
Amantadine.
- Scott
---------------------------------------------------------------
6: Br J Pharmacol 1999 Feb;126(3):689-96An in vitro electrophysiological study on the effects of phenytoin,
lamotrigine and gabapentin on striatal neurons.Calabresi P, Centonze D, Marfia GA, Pisani A, Bernardi G
Dip. Sanita, Universita di Roma Tor Vergata, Rome, Italy.
calabre@uniroma2.itWe performed intracellular recordings from a rat corticostriatal
slice preparation in order to compare the electrophysiological
effects of the classical antiepileptic drug (AED) phenytoin (PHT)
and the new AEDs lamotrigine (LTG) and gabapentin (GBP) on striatal
neurons. PHT, LTG and GBP affected neither the resting membrane
potential nor the input resistance/membrane conductance of the
recorded cells. In contrast, these agents depressed in a
dose-dependent and reversible manner the current-evoked repetitive
firing discharge. These AEDs also reduced the amplitude of
glutamatergic excitatory postsynaptic potentials (EPSPs) evoked by
cortical stimulation. However, substantial pharmacological
differences between these drugs were found. PHT was the most
effective and potent agent in reducing sustained repetitive firing
of action potentials, whereas LTG and GBP preferentially inhibited
corticostriatal excitatory transmission. Concentrations of LTG and
GBP effective in reducing EPSPs, in fact, produced only a slight
inhibition of the firing activity of these cells. LTG, but not PHT
and GBP, depressed cortically-evoked EPSPs increasing paired-pulse
facilitation (PPF) of synaptic transmission, suggesting that a
presynaptic site of action was implicated in the effect of this
drug. Accordingly, PHT and GBP, but not LTG reduced the membrane
depolarizations induced by exogenously-applied glutamate,
suggesting that these drugs preferentially reduce postsynaptic
sensitivity to glutamate released from corticostriatal terminals.
These data indicate that in the striatum PHT, LTG and GBP decrease
neuronal excitability by modulating multiple sites of action. The
preferential modulation of excitatory synaptic transmission may
represent the cellular substrate for the therapeutic effects of new
AEDs whose use may be potentially extended to the therapy of
neurodegenerative diseases involving the basal ganglia.PMID: 10188980, UI: 99202863
Posted by Noa on January 2, 2001, at 11:18:11
In reply to Re: Scott- Lamotrigine's AD/dopaminergic action, posted by SLS on January 2, 2001, at 10:34:27
SLS, you are right--the term Bipolar III is being used to describe depressions with AD-induced hypomania. I just read this in the following abstract:
I could swear I remember reading a previous abstract of work by Akiskal in which he uses BPIII to refer to recurrent depression. Oh well.
I also thought I would mention, as I was reminded when perusing the abstracts, that one of the reasons why these researchers believe there is a diagnostic relationship between recurrent depression and bipolar is that for many people, recurrent depression takes the so called "atypical" form--with "reverse vegetative signs", like hypERsomnia, INcreased appetite, and also have some mood reactivity, whereas "typical" (to me "typical" vs. "atypical" are misnomers) depression, usually non-recurrent, is more often associated with vegetative signs like DEcreased appetite, INsomnia, etc. and very little reactivity (ie, can your depression loosen a bit to allow you to laugh at a joke, etc.).
So, it might also help to ask if your depression falls into either of these types.
And, I also want to say that sometimes mood stabilizers do have AD effect, on their own, or in combo with ADs, regardless of diagnosis.
Regardless of Diagnosis is a point I keep repeating, because I agree with SLS about focusing on the specific experience and treating symptoms or clusters of symtoms and not worrying too much about diagnosis. Every few years, the dx categories change a bit anyway.
Posted by Ted R on January 2, 2001, at 23:51:54
In reply to S.D.- some more thoughts, posted by judy1 on January 1, 2001, at 12:52:10
> Hi Neighbor,
> Yes, Dr. Akiskal and the full professors at UCSD (Zisook another bipolar expert there) do not accept patients anymore; I was able to get a consultation because I am "interesting", a treatment resistant rapid cycler with a loaded family history. Anyway, one of the important factors that came out of that meeting was a ban on antidepressants and a trial on lamictal- which worked TOO well. Have you tried it yet, it is considered the one mood stabilizer with an antidepressant effect and it really does work well in a lot of people. As far as the more mainstream mood stabilizers, no they don't prevent depression in most people dxed with bipolar- even lithium according to more recent developments. I'm glad you went to Dr. Phelp's site (sp?), he also hates AD's, even with someone who has a somewhat muddled picture like you. Although you did allude to possible hypomanic states, which people tend to downplay because they feel good. As far as cycles, I've cycled in 1 day- and there are people who do so hourly (ultra-rapid), and often get confused with borderline- another disorder Akiskal puts on the bipolar spectrum. I realize a lot of his stuff is presented as posters at meetings and may not be published. I think I'm drifting here, but as some one else suggested, don't worry about the semantics, just find something that works. And I would try lamictal- good luck, Judy
> With anxious depression being the main symptomology, could lamictal really exacerbate the anxiety? I suppose I should really follow my doc's advice and see if my problem is this Special Bipolar 2 diagnosis, but the overactivating possibility of lamictal concerns me. I hate to be vague, but whether or not a person is considered to be unipolar depressed or this newer Bipolar explanation,the control and management of the painful symptoms is all that I want.
Posted by AndrewB on January 3, 2001, at 3:05:41
In reply to Re: Scott- Lamotrigine's AD/dopaminergic action, posted by SLS on January 2, 2001, at 10:34:27
Scott,
I am very busy this week, I will try to answer your questions as soon as possible. Glutaminergic dysfunction is inplicated in physical ailments (i.e gluacoma, hearing loss, neuropathic pain), neurologal deterioration (neuron die off due to excess calcium influx), depression, seizure and cycling activity, cognitive impairiment, schizpophrenia and the list goes on.
Perhaps it is relevant that the glutaminergic system is the largest nuerotramitter system in the brain. Moreover, it has significant pathways into and between the hippocampus, medial prefrontal cortex and the shell of the nucleus accumbens. These are areas of the brain amoung the most responsive and vulnerable (to damage from) stress. For example it was recently shown that excitoxic lesions in the hippocampus impair the emotional conditioning and led to additional glutamate release in the n. accumbens.
Anyway, some drugs are out there to halt in some aspects the damage of various types of glutaminergic dysfunction and restore normal function. Many more are in the investigational stage. I plan to try to learn further what meds are curently available for the beneficial manipulation of parts of the glutaminergic system in order to deal with certain health disorders.
Best wishes,
AndrewB
Posted by judy1 on January 3, 2001, at 19:20:02
In reply to Re: S.D.- some more thoughts, posted by Ted R on January 2, 2001, at 23:51:54
Hi Ted,
I started lamictal with depakote and klonopin in place, so I really didn't experience any increase in panic attacks or anxiety. Are you on a benzo for anxiety? If you start out low and slow- 25mgs for the first week (actually I did 12.5 because of the depakote), you should be able to judge your rx pretty well. At 100mgs, I was absolutely euphoric, gee maybe I should take it again- Judy
Posted by Ted R on January 3, 2001, at 23:35:39
In reply to Re: S.D.- some more thoughts » Ted R, posted by judy1 on January 3, 2001, at 19:20:02
> Hi Ted,
> I started lamictal with depakote and klonopin in place, so I really didn't experience any increase in panic attacks or anxiety. Are you on a benzo for anxiety? If you start out low and slow- 25mgs for the first week (actually I did 12.5 because of the depakote), you should be able to judge your rx pretty well. At 100mgs, I was absolutely euphoric, gee maybe I should take it again- Judy
>Judy, thanks for your advice. I have on hand tranxene and also xanax when a PA may develope, but lately I have been taking more of the xanax with the Welbutrin, because xanax was offering some additional AD effect, and taking the normal dose of tranxene began to add to the depression. I believe that a trial on lamictal may well be worth it. Because with the exception of 150 to 200mgs a day of Wellbutrin SR, the entire realm of ADs, I have already tried, I have not gotten through the side effects, loss of libido, spaciness etc. thanks again...Ted
Posted by S.D. on January 5, 2001, at 15:38:23
In reply to Re: S.D.- some more thoughts, posted by Ted R on January 3, 2001, at 23:35:39
>Because with the exception of 150 to 200mgs a day
>of Wellbutrin SR, the entire realm of ADs, I
>have already tried, I have not gotten through the
>side effects, loss of libido, spaciness etc.The "150 to 200mgs a day of Wellbutrin SR" got my attention because they always say 300mg qd is the minimum therapeutic dose. Though in reality I guess it is the amount in one's body that matters, and 300mg/day is only the amount believed needed to achieve that for most people with normal metabolism.
So I was wondering, were you getting a significant antidepressant effect from 150-200/day?
I wasn't sure if I should post this becaus no doubt your doctor knows this already and there's a reason for it, like that something else you were/are taking decreases the metabolism of the Wellbutrin.
S.D.
Posted by S.D. on January 5, 2001, at 17:30:24
In reply to Re: Bipolar type that cycles betw norm. and depressed? » S.D., posted by SLS on January 1, 2001, at 9:45:11
> Hi S.D.
>
> Yes, there are bipolar and "soft" bipolar (not meeting strict diagnostic criteria for bipolar disorder) presentations that exhibit a cycling between depressed and normothymic states. I personally experienced a period of two years in which I was an ultra-rapid cycler, switching between severe depression and nearly normal (mild depressive) states regularly with a period of 11 days. 3 days up and 8 days down. Like clockwork. Damned biological clocks. Upon my first trial of lithium, rapid cyclicity ceased and left me chronically depressed thereafter.
>
> At no time during my rapid-cycling period did mania or hypomania appear. In fact, the only time they do now is when a medication precipitates it. My manic states during these events have been either mixed or dysphoric. Depressions that include antidepressant-induced manias (but no spontaneous manias) has been proposed as bipolar type III (contradictory to the work cited by Noa)
>to be included in the DSM diagnostic manual for
>over a decade.
>
>I suppose I'm dysphoric or mixed much of the time that I'm depressed. Only sometimes is it *pure* depression, but I may be splitting hairs. It is pure enough to be Dx'd that way by any pdoc (with a side of anxiety, but that is traditionally always considered separate, and in my case subsyndromal anyway).
It's rather like this quote the abstract Noa referenced:
( http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&list_uids=11121824&dopt=Abstract )
< blockquote >...depressive mixed states consisting of few hypomanic symptoms (i.e., racing thoughts, sexual arousal) during full-blown major depressive episodes - included in Kraepelin's schema of mixed states, but excluded by DSM-IV.
< /blockquote >> Why do you think you have a cycle between states?
Maybe 'cycle' is not the right word, although my pdoc told me yesterday that cycling even in classic bipolars does not have to be regular (constant period). I've never had shifts that were anything like yours or that had a constant period (unless a very long one so I haven't perceived it).
**
If cycle doesn't imply constant period, then anyone who has had more than one Major Depressive episode 'has a cycle between states'. I've not found any abstracts about trials showing 'mood stabilizers' (other than adjunctive lithium) are significant for people with this Dx/presentation. (That was my essential purpose in posting the query that started this thread.) But if not, I don't know what would be the point of broadening the idea of bipolar, or the "spectrum of bipolar", as sumarized in these words from the abstract Noa referenced:( http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&list_uids=11121824&dopt=Abstract )
< blockquote >'softer' clinical expressions of bipolarity situated between the extremes of full-blown bipolar disorder where the person has at least one manic episode (bipolar I) and strictly defined unipolar major depressive disorder without personal or family history for excited periods
< /blockquote >
**> Can you describe the details of your cycle and
> what you feel in both states?What I originally described was just Vanilla major depression as one state and either normal or dysthymic as the other. The paragraphs above, between the '**' marks, explains why someone like that would be bothering about all this.
In my case what I called almost normal I really feel is dysthymia. Which I guess is a way of saying "I hope this isn't really as good as it gets, because this is pretty lame. Whatever happiness is, I don't think I'm experiencing what normal people experience.")
To put it in more detail... since age 8 or earlier, maybe always, I think I've had dysthymia; and that since age 14 I've had what history-taking doctors have considered a few distinct major depressive episodes that have lasted around 3 months to 2 years.
( http://www.graylab.ac.uk/cgi-bin/omd?query=dysthymia )
I could elaborate to say I could maybe identify 5 'states' that don't necessarily corrospond to anything and may have different periods (probably no consistant period):
1) Major depressive episode, of the ho-hum DSM kind.
2) Mixed state of depression mostly as above, but also two or more of agitation, irritability, anxiety, racing thoughts. Similar to "depression with flight of ideas" first described by Kraepelin.
3) my normal dysthymic self. I can distinguish it from (1), above, because I don't spend as much time thinking about being better off dead. But fatigue and anhedonia and tendency toward anxiety remain.
4) disturbed sleep only - multi-week or multi-month stretches. Usually insomnia, but a long hypersomnia once and probably a few shortish ones.
5) What I'll call euthymic. Cured, if it would stay that way. I guess that doesn't have to be the same thing as 'happy', so I don't have to try to figure out what that feels like. This has probably happened a few times, for up to maybe several months. Most recently while on an AD.> Personally, I feel that mood-stabilizer medications are a good idea in situations like this to help prevent the condition from evolving into a more severe and treatment-resistant course.
>
> I agree in many ways with Noa regarding diagnosis based upon response or non-response to
>mood-stabilizers, especially when they seem to be
>helpful in cases currently thought to be unipolar.
>
My pdoc also said they (and not just lithium) are used this way. But I still can't find any trial results (e.g. valproate, carbamazepine, lamictal).> I guess all of this garbage is my feeble attempt to squeeze out any true rapid cyclicity ...
> ... or whether your illness is simply a recurrent unipolar depression that is best treated consistently and without "drug-holidays" indefinitely.
>
>Definitely no true rapid cyclicity. It can certainly be seen as simple recurrent unipolar depression, comorbid with an anxiety disorder ( I have other anxiety too, but 'subsyndromal' I guess since it doesn't seem to qualify as GAD ).
And it may not even be all that treatment-resistant if I can find an AD I can tolerate.
> No need to respond - just a few things to think about.*Now* you tell me.
>
> - ScottS.D.
Posted by S.D. on January 5, 2001, at 18:00:41
In reply to S.D.- some more thoughts, posted by judy1 on January 1, 2001, at 12:52:10
> Hi Neighbor,
> Yes, Dr. Akiskal and the full professors at UCSD
>(Zisook another bipolar expert there) do not accept patients anymore;Another San Diegan! cool.
I think I read in another of your posts that you are married which is great because your husband is probably a great source of support for you.I'm guessing you know about this already, but if a typical support group kind of thing is something you'd be interested in there's a chapter of the NDMDA that meets Every monday at 6pm in room 2011 of the UCSD VA hospital in LJ.
Every other meeting there's a speaker the first hour.BTW I'm curious about something you posted in a reply about clon.:
"my pdoc feels panic/bipolar is intertwined with seizure disorders. "
When I posted asking if a normal-to-depressed cycle could be bipolar it was at the prompting of my mother who had heard something to that effect. I had never considered it (no family history, although my mother's ancesters are unknown.) and probably wouldn't have gone ahead and inquired except for one tidbit: my father and brother had/have some form of epilepsy/seizure.
I had a hunch about that since "mood stabilizer" == "Anticonvulsant/AED" in several cases.
I don't know if epilepsy has been shown to be hereditary similar to Bipolar but if so, then if 'bipolar genes' are found it could also confirm the connection to epilepsy.I was wondering who that pdoc is. I'll understand if you don't want to say.
peace and health,
S.D.
Posted by SLS on January 5, 2001, at 21:08:44
In reply to Re: Bipolar type that cycles betw norm. and depressed? » SLS, posted by S.D. on January 5, 2001, at 17:30:24
Dear S.D.,
> > No need to respond - just a few things to think about.
>
> *Now* you tell me.I always read the punchline first so that I can better understand the rest of the joke when I read it for the first time. :-)
Frustrating, isn't it. I wish I could help you pinpoint the right treatment for you to be "cured". Me too, while I'm at it.
> And it may not even be all that treatment-resistant if I can find an AD I can tolerate.
With which ADs have you experienced a significant antidepressant effect? What side effects of these drugs did you find intolerable? Very often, the side effects themselves need to be treated. If there is one drug that is a standout as far as improvement of your depression is concerned, perhaps you could get some feedback here as to how to remedy the side effects. For instance, I could not tolerate a combination of Nardil + imipramine. My blood pressure was so low, that I had to crawl around the house to avoid passing-out. I would just about bust a gut every time I tried to urinate. Florinef fixes #1 and bethanecol fixes #2. Over time, after the body makes some adjustments, one can often tolerate such a combination and discontinue the remedial drugs.
> Definitely no true rapid cyclicity. It can certainly be seen as simple recurrent unipolar depression, comorbid with an anxiety disorder ( I have other anxiety too, but 'subsyndromal' I guess since it doesn't seem to qualify as GAD ).
Rapid cyclicity is defined by the DSM IV as being the occurrence of four or more mood episodes (not cycles) over a one year period. I guess you gotta start somewhere. It seems a bit arbitrary to me, but I think it has value. There is no mention of a regularity of cycles.
If you are looking for accurate diagnoses for the purpose of choosing those treatments most likely to fix the problem, I should think that it was worth the effort to have made your inquiry. It is relevant. However, sometimes it comes down to a best guess. Sometimes not even that. Things can get pretty fuzzy. That's why the idea of a spectrum is useful.
Perhaps you suffer from an agitated major depression superimposed upon dysthymia - a double depression. The "agitated" would help explain the anxiety and even the racing thoughts. You haven't mentioned sex. That's O.K. I'm not in the mood anyway. However, the presence of hypersexuality would help differentiate an agitated depression from a bipolar mixed-state. Either way, perhaps Depakote or lithium would help. For agitated depressions, I think tricyclics are worth pursuing. Right now, I wouldn't know which of them to recommend - maybe nortriptyline or Sinequan.
Do you eat too much or too little when you are in the middle of a serious depression?
Do you experience insomnia, particularly in the early morning (3:00am-5:00am) when seriously depressed?
- Scott
Posted by judy1 on January 9, 2001, at 11:46:30
In reply to Re: Hi neighbor (was Re: S.D.- some more thoughts) » judy1, posted by S.D. on January 5, 2001, at 18:00:41
Hi S.D,
Sorry for not getting back sooner, I have had somewhat of a setback. The pdoc I am seeing is connected with UCLA and prominant (you'll figure it out). Anyway, with your background of epilepsy I think a THOROUGH neuro work-up should be considered (not just an EEG). Even though the treatment for bipolar and complex partial seizures, what they think I have is the same, and AED's are effective in panic disorder, I'm sure you feel it would be nice to have a precise dx. Thank you for the NDMDA info, I have tried group sessions and failed- I have had some of my worst panic attacks then. I hope you find them helpful. I am going to see someone local today (recommended by the UCSD group), I'll let you know how it works out. Thank you for posting the info on Dr. Stahl, I have heard the name- did he give you the wrong meds? Take care- Judy
Posted by phillybob on January 9, 2001, at 13:17:24
In reply to Re: Hi neighbor (was Re: S.D.- some more thoughts) » S.D., posted by judy1 on January 9, 2001, at 11:46:30
S.D. and Judi:
Not sure how much info is out there on this, as these posts are the first I've heard of it. But, we have some serious BP (mood instability, at least) in our family and one of our parents has had a couple of seizures ... I'm wonderin' if the anti-seizure medication had helped this individual control unspoken of mood swings? hmmm.... interesting ... I'm tryin' topamax (anti-seizure) right now for dysthymic (see topamax posts) with some positive effects so far.
Posted by Noa on January 9, 2001, at 15:51:47
In reply to Re: Seizures and BP, posted by phillybob on January 9, 2001, at 13:17:24
Judy, does the doc think your dissociation is seizure-related?
Posted by judy1 on January 10, 2001, at 0:11:09
In reply to Re: Seizures and BP, posted by Noa on January 9, 2001, at 15:51:47
Hi Noa,
This is an area of great interest to him- a lot of my symptoms mimic TLE (including the SI and auditory hallucinations) and I was scheduled for a complete work-up with an epileptologist (brain mapping, etc.) I will have to reschedule, I'm just not up to it right now. Take care, Judy
Posted by SLS on January 10, 2001, at 10:03:44
In reply to Re: Seizures and BP » Noa, posted by judy1 on January 10, 2001, at 0:11:09
> Hi Noa,
> This is an area of great interest to him- a lot of my symptoms mimic TLE (including the SI and auditory hallucinations) and I was scheduled for a complete work-up with an epileptologist (brain mapping, etc.) I will have to reschedule, I'm just not up to it right now. Take care, JudyHey Judy,
Have you tried Neurontin? Perhaps in combination with another anticonvulsant/mood-stabilizer. Maybe Depakote or Lamictal
I'm not sure, but I think it is especially effective for temporal lobe disturbances, especially if anxiety or social anxiety is present.
I'll be curious to follow your progress. Good luck.
Sincerely,
Scott
Posted by SLS on January 10, 2001, at 10:13:21
In reply to Re: Seizures and BP » judy1, posted by SLS on January 10, 2001, at 10:03:44
Dear Judy,
I'm sorry to bug you again, but I had a thought on my way to the bathroom. Have you been screened for schizoaffective disorder?
Gotta' go. Still.
- Scott
Posted by judy1 on January 10, 2001, at 12:03:51
In reply to Re: Seizures and BP » judy1, posted by SLS on January 10, 2001, at 10:03:44
Hi Scott,
Unfortunately Neurontin did nothing for me, and I am sadly admitting that because it is one of the few drugs that had no side-effects, except for some dissociation around 3000mg. And yes I took it in combo with depakote, but can't remember if I took it with lamictal (which I'm on now)- something to check with out with my shrink. Thank you for your suggestions and the good luck. Take care, Judy
Posted by judy1 on January 10, 2001, at 12:11:55
In reply to Re: Seizures and BP, posted by SLS on January 10, 2001, at 10:13:21
You are too funny. What is the screening for schizoaffective disorder entail? When I was 19 and hospitalized for (what now is being labelled psychotic mania) I was dxed shizophrenic, which I understand to be fairly common. I'm confused about the whole schizoaffective thing anyway- psychoses between mood episodes? What if you're always cycling, how could they dx that? Thank you- Judy
Posted by SLS on January 10, 2001, at 15:02:58
In reply to Re: Seizures and BP » SLS, posted by judy1 on January 10, 2001, at 12:11:55
Hi Judy.
> You are too funny.
So I've been told.
> What is the screening for schizoaffective disorder entail? When I was 19 and hospitalized for (what now is being labelled psychotic mania) I was dxed shizophrenic, which I understand to be fairly common. I'm confused about the whole schizoaffective thing anyway- psychoses between mood episodes? What if you're always cycling, how could they dx that? Thank you- Judy
Your descriptions of a combination of auditory hallucinations and bipolar characteristics are reminiscent of schizoaffective disorder. Schizoaffective disorder is its own entity. In other words, it is a single disorder rather than two separate disorders combined (comorbid presentation). If you have never heard of it, then perhaps this possibility was discounted by your physicians without verbalizing their diagnostic processes to you. However, if this has not been the case, in my opinion, it should be considered as a possible diagnosis. It would explain why your current treatments are inadequate.
The following description may be outdated, but it will certainly give you an idea if you think it should be pursued.
http://www.mentalhealth.com/dis1/p21-ps05.html
I wish for you only good things.
- Scott
Posted by SLS on January 10, 2001, at 17:01:03
In reply to Re: Seizures and BP, posted by SLS on January 10, 2001, at 15:02:58
Dear Judy,
It is important to recognize that there is still much debate as to the diagnostic criteria for schizoaffective disorders. Many researchers feel that the requirements for delusions and hallucinations are given too much weight. Don't worry if you don't match exactly the recipe of requirements. (1 from column A, 2 from column B for at least 2 weeks, etc.)
- Scott
> Your descriptions of a combination of auditory hallucinations and bipolar characteristics are reminiscent of schizoaffective disorder. Schizoaffective disorder is its own entity. In other words, it is a single disorder rather than two separate disorders combined (comorbid presentation). If you have never heard of it, then perhaps this possibility was discounted by your physicians without verbalizing their diagnostic processes to you. However, if this has not been the case, in my opinion, it should be considered as a possible diagnosis. It would explain why your current treatments are inadequate.> The following description may be outdated, but it will certainly give you an idea if you think it should be pursued.
Posted by judy1 on January 11, 2001, at 0:30:27
In reply to Re: Seizures and BP, posted by SLS on January 10, 2001, at 17:01:03
I'll ask Scott, I'm thinking nobody considered this dx because for a 10 year period (until 3 years ago), I was very 'high functioning'. I am on a low dose of risperdal (2mg) and that seems to keep the auditory hallucinations at bay. Thank you very much for your input- Judy
Posted by S.D. on January 13, 2001, at 1:30:01
In reply to Re: Hi neighbor (was Re: S.D.- some more thoughts) » S.D., posted by judy1 on January 9, 2001, at 11:46:30
>Thank you for the NDMDA info, I have tried group sessions
>and failed- I have had some of my worst panic attacks
>then. I hope you find them helpful.Depite the name NDMDA, almost all of the people that come are highly bipolar whereas I am pretty much purely unipolar depressive. We tend to have different histories and issues. I am going to try a NAMI meeting this month. But I've volunteered to advise the DMDA group on establishing a web site in support of the support group, and to implement whatever is decided.
> I am going to see
>someone local today (recommended by the UCSD group), I'll
>let you know how it works out. Thank you for posting the
>info on Dr. Stahl, I have heard the name- did he give you
>the wrong meds? Take care- JudyI don't want to make too big of a deal about it because I don't doubt he is an effective psychopharmacologist. We decided I would go off of Parnate to try Paxil since I also have social anxiety disorder. I was certain I would suffer effects if I quit cold turkey ( I had just about run out of meds from another doc's Rx) but he was confident it was no problem and I didn't find anything on Pubmed to prove myself right.
After 2 days of bizarre nightmares and a couple weeks of flu/insomnia/spacey symptoms, I found in the Physician's Desk Reference: "should be discontinued gradually" but it didn't elaborate so I can see how it could be forgotten if he didn't prescribe it often. I probably wasn't insistant enough with him, due to the social phobia.
Similar thing had happened previously on Nardil, but they had warned me that time. Interestingly, the nightmares had a (different) consistant theme in each case. Nardil knocks out your REM (dream) sleep, so that probably relates to the wierd, scary-ass dreams when you quit.
peace and health,
S.D.
Posted by JahL on January 13, 2001, at 12:06:41
In reply to reply re: NDMDA, bad result with pdoc » judy1, posted by S.D. on January 13, 2001, at 1:30:01
> > Thank you for posting the info on Dr. Stahl, I have heard the name- did he give you
the wrong meds? Take care- Judy
>
> I don't want to make too big of a deal about it because I don't doubt he is an effective psychopharmacologist. We decided I would go off of Parnate to try Paxil since I also have social anxiety disorder. I was certain I would suffer effects if I quit cold turkey ( I had just about run out of meds from another doc's Rx) but he was confident it was no problem and I didn't find anything on Pubmed to prove myself right.
>
> After 2 days of bizarre nightmares and a couple weeks of flu/insomnia/spacey symptoms, I found in the Physician's Desk Reference: "should be discontinued gradually" but it didn't elaborate so I can see how it could be forgotten if he didn't prescribe it often. I probably wasn't insistant enough with him, due to the social phobia.Mmmm...
I had the misfortune to be referred, here in the UK, to 2 former, eminent, colleagues of Dr Stahl whom I can honestly say were a disgrace to their profession (tho' they spoke v. highly of Stahl)
Not that this in any way reflects upon the good Dr Stahl.....
Jah.
Posted by judy1 on January 13, 2001, at 14:12:27
In reply to Re: reply re: NDMDA, bad result with pdoc, posted by JahL on January 13, 2001, at 12:06:41
Wow! It is a small world. I know most people don't like to post bad experiences with a particular pdoc (me included), but when I read something like this I'm thankful to that person for saving me from a bad experience. It seems that if you go to a "renowned" specialist, and pay the big bucks because of course your insurance isn't going to cover it, you should expect a positive, helping experience. I told my 100 miles away pdoc that I have given up trying to find a local one and just accept the drive. I hope you have found someone good. Take care, Judy
Posted by judy1 on January 13, 2001, at 14:25:32
In reply to reply re: NDMDA, bad result with pdoc » judy1, posted by S.D. on January 13, 2001, at 1:30:01
Hi S.D.,
I was amazed to see that JahL knew of your pdoc, I thought if you were trying someone new and wanted to ask the forum if they had experiences with him/her (positive or negative), maybe they or I could help. I've been through 14 in the last year- don't ask- so I do know quite a few locally. I am extremely sensitive (maybe that is like your social phobia), so I get triggered very easily and have been known to just run out the door. I hope your NAMI meetings go well, and I think that's really kind of you to help the DMDA group. Take care, Judy
This is the end of the thread.
Psycho-Babble Medication | Extras | FAQ
Dr. Bob is Robert Hsiung, MD,
bob@dr-bob.org
Script revised: February 4, 2008
URL: http://www.dr-bob.org/cgi-bin/pb/mget.pl
Copyright 2006-17 Robert Hsiung.
Owned and operated by Dr. Bob LLC and not the University of Chicago.