![[dr. bob]](/dr-bob-sm.gif)
Dr. Bob is Robert Hsiung, MD,
bob@dr-bob.orgShown: posts 13 to 37 of 64. Go back in thread:
Posted by phidippus on August 21, 2012, at 19:58:15
In reply to Re: Too bad we aren't well enough to be scientists » phidippus, posted by SLS on August 21, 2012, at 19:49:46
Only if the shower is really cold. Nothing like self abuse to stir the spirits.
Eric
Posted by SLS on August 21, 2012, at 20:33:52
In reply to Re: Too bad we aren't well enough to be scientists » SLS, posted by phidippus on August 21, 2012, at 16:31:58
> The trick to defeating depression is doing something, no matter how hard.
>
> I was suicidal when I composed a track for a Mercedes commercial. I was so depressed I could hardly move.
I think the most pervasive mistake made by people on Psycho-Babble (and elsewhere) is to attempt to compare their experience with mental illness to those of others, and to question another's resolve to function at any given level.It sounds as if you are saying that I could have defeated my depression long ago if I had only known the trick to "do something". What didn't I do? What do I continue not to do? When did you first discover this "trick"? Are you now cured of mental illness such that you can discontinue treatment? If not, then why haven't you defeated your illness by "doing something"?
You say that you could "hardly" move when you composed a track for a Mercedes commercial. Can you better describe this experience? I would like to compare it to what I have seen in others.
- Scott
Posted by Raisinb on August 21, 2012, at 22:33:17
In reply to Re: Too bad we aren't well enough to be scientists » phidippus, posted by SLS on August 21, 2012, at 20:33:52
I've been in states where I was so frantically doing everything I could think of to defeat my depression that I induced way more dysphoria because I was constantly beating myself up for not doing more or different things. Depression is great for inducing binds like that.
Posted by SLS on August 21, 2012, at 23:02:31
In reply to Re: Too bad we aren't well enough to be scientists » SLS, posted by Raisinb on August 21, 2012, at 22:33:17
> I've been in states where I was so frantically doing everything I could think of to defeat my depression that I induced way more dysphoria because I was constantly beating myself up for not doing more or different things. Depression is great for inducing binds like that.
Have you always had high expectations of yourself?
I did.
Perfectionism can be depressogenic.
At some point, I realized just how great an achievement it was to survive with this illness. It was a bitter pill to swallow to lose my intellect and operate at a level way beneath those around me.
I push. I push. I push. I constantly push. It grows tiresome, but I keep pushing. I often succeed. Succeed in what? I succeed in trying. Failure to achieve the goals set forth by others is okay with me. It has to be. I must acknowledge that my illness places upon me limitations that most of the people around me do not have. Thus, my expectation of myself is to try to use all of what little God gives me to work with.
- Scott
Posted by phidippus on August 22, 2012, at 6:49:14
In reply to Re: Too bad we aren't well enough to be scientists » Raisinb, posted by SLS on August 21, 2012, at 23:02:31
>I must acknowledge that my illness places upon me >limitations that most of the people around me do >not have.
My heart goes out to you, Scott. I wish we could hang out and play some co-op Portal 2.
There's something off, though. My intuition tells me that your basic attitude toward your illness is one of ill-fate. You speak of limitations when you should be seeing potential. You are not stuck. God has not handed you an ultimatum. If anything, he has given you a challenge you seem to overcome on a daily basis. I don't see you as functioning at some lower level. You have a beautiful mind that you have excercised well and can use without a moments hesitation. In fact, I'm jealous of your insight at times.
So, there is no doubt your intellectual functioning has not been comprimised. What, then is the real issue? Tell me about your depression and how it effects you.
On another note, maybe you need to rethink your medication regimen.
Eric
Posted by phidippus on August 22, 2012, at 6:51:09
In reply to Re: Too bad we aren't well enough to be scientists » SLS, posted by Raisinb on August 21, 2012, at 22:33:17
You make me want to cry. I suffer the same exact thing. Nothing like pacing around agitated because I've convinced myself I need to be doing more.
Eric
Posted by Alexei on August 22, 2012, at 7:35:55
In reply to Re: Too bad we aren't well enough to be scientists » SLS, posted by Raisinb on August 21, 2012, at 22:33:17
> I've been in states where I was so frantically doing everything I could think of to defeat my depression that I induced way more dysphoria because I was constantly beating myself up for not doing more or different things. Depression is great for inducing binds like that.
Yes, I've had the same thing happen many times. I would run myself into the ground with endless activity, attempting to chase my depression away, or move at insane speeds to try to out run it.
Neither one worked. It's not something I can outrun or beat into submission. I had to change my approach.
Posted by phidippus on August 22, 2012, at 7:57:39
In reply to Re: Too bad we aren't well enough to be scientists » phidippus, posted by SLS on August 21, 2012, at 20:33:52
>I think the most pervasive mistake made by people >on Psycho-Babble (and elsewhere) is to attempt to >compare their experience with mental illness to >those of others, and to question another's resolve >to function at any given level.
Why is it a mistake to compare my depression with another's? All around, the guises depression takes can be remarkably similar, hence our ability to relate with one another on this very site. We wouldn't be handing out advice if each experience were exotic.
>It sounds as if you are saying that I could have >defeated my depression long ago if I had only >known the trick to "do something
There's no trick and I never said long ago in a galaxy far far away...I'm saying if you keep doing, you will chip away at your depression-maybe not 'defeat' it, but reduce its control of your life.
>What didn't I do? What do I continue not to do?
Are you going to school? Do you have a job? Do you volunteer? Do you answer personal ads on Craigslist? Do you take dancing lessons? Have you hiked a 14er?
I would like to know more about what you do.
>When did you first discover this "trick"?
Its not a trick. Its something that works. I blame years of CBT, DBT and counseling. My therapist is always on me to keep doing stuff, keeping busy. It provides structure and keeps the mind from wandering into shark infested waters.
>Are you now cured of mental illness such that >you can discontinue treatment? If not, then why >haven't you defeated your illness by "doing >something"?
Now, now, Scott. It appears I am paying for saying 'defeating' or 'defeated'. A little touchy about my choice in rhetoric? And yes, the remission of my OCD is partly due to 'doing something'.
>you say that you could "hardly" move
Motor retardation. I felt like I was moving in Jello. I had a hard time manipulating the mouse and keyboard on my music workstation and everything seemed to be moving in slow motion-especially my thoughts. I also had this feeling that I just wanted to die.
I've been so depressed before I incurred Cotard Syndrome-the belief I was dead. Zyprexa helped with that.
>Can you better describe this experience? I would >like to compare it to what I have seen in others.
I thought it was a "pervasive mistake...to attempt to compare their experience with mental illness to those of others"?
By the way, Scott, I don't mean to offend you or piss you off. Come over and we'll play some Portal 2.
Eric
Posted by phidippus on August 22, 2012, at 7:59:45
In reply to Re: Too bad we aren't well enough to be scientists » Raisinb, posted by Alexei on August 22, 2012, at 7:35:55
How did you change your approach?
Eric
Posted by Raisinb on August 22, 2012, at 10:57:01
In reply to Re: Too bad we aren't well enough to be scientists » Raisinb, posted by SLS on August 21, 2012, at 23:02:31
Yes, and all my therapists tell me not to be so hard on myself. Not that it's that easy. I can't wake up and not be profoundly disappointed and angry at myself for not meeting my own expectations,
I wish there was an award or something for surviving with years of depressive illness. We all deserve it,
Posted by Raisinb on August 22, 2012, at 11:00:42
In reply to Re: Too bad we aren't well enough to be scientists » Raisinb, posted by Alexei on August 22, 2012, at 7:35:55
What did you change your approach to? How did you do things differently? I often still get stuck in this bind. It's really tough not to for me.
Posted by SLS on August 22, 2012, at 11:14:19
In reply to Re: Too bad we aren't well enough to be scientists » SLS, posted by phidippus on August 22, 2012, at 7:57:39
Eric.
You just don't get it.
Maybe you never had it.
Perhaps you once had it, but have quickly forgotten what it's like to have it.
You assume too much about me as you attempt to see me through eyes that never will. I exist to you only in words posted electronically. You don't even know how long it takes for me to type those words.
I am feeling better. I can read whole paragraphs now, but still not consecutively. Interestingly, I can write ten if I had to.
Anyway, you still make the mistake of judging the illness of others based upon your own experience, and expect them to be able to mirror your abilities. You expect people to chip away at their depression when they might not be able to even lift the hammer.
Depression has many faces. It takes an expert to be able to recognize them all. No two depressions look alike just as no two brains function alike. I am no expert and try not of quantify the suffering of others, especially publicly. What would motivate you to so with me? Am I too unintelligent to have thought to chip away at my illness as you have yours? Perhaps I am just lazy?
> Are you going to school? Do you have a job? Do you volunteer? Do you answer personal ads on Craigslist? Do you take dancing lessons? Have you hiked a 14er?
You just don't get it.
> > Can you better describe this experience? I would >like to compare it to what I have seen in others.
> I thought it was a "pervasive mistake...to attempt to compare their experience with mental illness to those of others"
It is. You missed the satire.
You are very knowledgeable about psychopharmacology and often give good advice about prescriptions for somatic treatments. I need as many ideas as I can get. However, what I don't need are prescriptions for making adjustments to my psyche and how to use that psyche to develop strategies to cope with my depressive illness. You don't have a clue.
I'm sure your advice to me would be appropriate for some other people - just not me. For me, you were wrong.
- Scott
Posted by SLS on August 22, 2012, at 11:20:26
In reply to Re: Too bad we aren't well enough to be scientists » SLS, posted by Raisinb on August 22, 2012, at 10:57:01
> Yes, and all my therapists tell me not to be so hard on myself. Not that it's that easy. I can't wake up and not be profoundly disappointed and angry at myself for not meeting my own expectations,
My guess is that you are not expecting of yourself any more than a healthy person would expect of themselves. Be angry at your illness and not at yourself. You are not the culprit. You are not the irresponsible one. You are not the talentless one, You are not the lazy one. You are not the unaccomplished one. You are not your illness, despite it affecting every waking moment of your life.
> I wish there was an award or something for surviving with years of depressive illness. We all deserve it,
BIG TIME !!!!
- Scott
Posted by phidippus on August 22, 2012, at 12:54:22
In reply to Re: Too bad we aren't well enough to be scientists » phidippus, posted by SLS on August 22, 2012, at 11:14:19
>you just don't get it.
That's a lazy statement.
>You assume too much about me as you attempt to see >me through eyes that never will.
I assume nothing about you. And, wow, that was poetic.
>Anyway, you still make the mistake of judging >the illness of others based upon your own >experience, and expect them to be able to mirror >your abilities
Don't be silly. People stay where they want to, I have no say.
>You expect people to chip away at their >depression when they might not be able to even >lift the hammer
I expect nothing. I only give advice.
> Are you going to school? Do you have a job? Do >you volunteer? Do you answer personal ads on >Craigslist? Do you take dancing lessons? Have >you hiked a 14er?
>You just don't get it.
Just answer the damn questions and quit being so defensive.
>I'm sure your advice to me would be appropriate >for some other people - just not me. For me, you >were wrong.The only thing I was wrong about was in underestimating how defensive you can be ;)
Eric
Posted by Alexei on August 22, 2012, at 14:09:36
In reply to Re: Too bad we aren't well enough to be scientists » Alexei, posted by Raisinb on August 22, 2012, at 11:00:42
> What did you change your approach to? How did you do things differently? I often still get stuck in this bind. It's really tough not to for me.
First, I was absolutely convinced that I could "fix" my depression by filling every waking minute with productive activity ... school, work, outside jobs, athletics.
Obviously that sounds great, but not to the extreme that i took it, there was no way I could keep up that insane pace. I was running from myself, and crashed.
Now, I can see things differently. Peace and happiness will never come from me trying to achieve and conquer what normal society says I should. I've come to see that normal society and lifestyles are insane.
I still do a lot of things, but because I want to, not because of outside pressures and expectations. I hope this makes sense.
Posted by Alexei on August 22, 2012, at 14:16:17
In reply to Re: Too bad we aren't well enough to be scientists » Alexei, posted by phidippus on August 22, 2012, at 7:59:45
Phidippus... Ive been reading thru lots of threads, and you seem like you're doing quite well. May I ask what your med regime is?
Posted by phidippus on August 22, 2012, at 14:51:32
In reply to Re: Too bad we aren't well enough to be scientists » phidippus, posted by Alexei on August 22, 2012, at 14:16:17
I take:
1200 mg of Lithium
60 mg of Viibryd
10 mg of Abilify
2 mg of KlonopinEric
Posted by Tomatheus on August 22, 2012, at 14:54:40
In reply to Re: Too bad we aren't well enough to be scientists » SLS, posted by phidippus on August 22, 2012, at 12:54:22
> People stay where they want to
What people? Does this mean everybody, including the mentally challenged and those with severe brain injuries? What about people in comas? Are you saying that, for example, people who are mentally challenged don't go to college because they don't want to, because it sure seems like you are. Or are the mentally ill the only ones who stay where they want to, in your eyes?
Tomatheus
Posted by phidippus on August 22, 2012, at 15:37:22
In reply to Re: Too bad we aren't well enough to be scientists » phidippus, posted by Tomatheus on August 22, 2012, at 14:54:40
> Does this mean everybody, including the mentally >challenged and those with severe brain injuries?
Stephen Hawking.
People in comas? Yeah, I meant them too, f*ck*ng vegetables can wake up whenever they want.
If a mentally challenged person hasn't gone to college its because they don't want to. Nothing is stopping them.
John Nash
In my eyes, the mentally challenged can do whatever they want. That means stay put or become mega porn stars, whatever.
Beethoven
Eric
Posted by alchemy on August 22, 2012, at 18:34:48
In reply to Re: Too bad we aren't well enough to be scientists » phidippus, posted by SLS on August 22, 2012, at 11:14:19
> Eric.
>
> You just don't get it.
>
> Maybe you never had it.
>
> Perhaps you once had it, but have quickly forgotten what it's like to have it.
>
> You assume too much about me as you attempt to see me through eyes that never will. I exist to you only in words posted electronically. You don't even know how long it takes for me to type those words.
>
> I am feeling better. I can read whole paragraphs now, but still not consecutively. Interestingly, I can write ten if I had to.
>
> Anyway, you still make the mistake of judging the illness of others based upon your own experience, and expect them to be able to mirror your abilities. You expect people to chip away at their depression when they might not be able to even lift the hammer.
>
> Depression has many faces. It takes an expert to be able to recognize them all. No two depressions look alike just as no two brains function alike. I am no expert and try not of quantify the suffering of others, especially publicly. What would motivate you to so with me? Am I too unintelligent to have thought to chip away at my illness as you have yours? Perhaps I am just lazy?
>
> > Are you going to school? Do you have a job? Do you volunteer? Do you answer personal ads on Craigslist? Do you take dancing lessons? Have you hiked a 14er?
>
> You just don't get it.
>
> > > Can you better describe this experience? I would >like to compare it to what I have seen in others.
>
> > I thought it was a "pervasive mistake...to attempt to compare their experience with mental illness to those of others"
>
> It is. You missed the satire.
>
> You are very knowledgeable about psychopharmacology and often give good advice about prescriptions for somatic treatments. I need as many ideas as I can get. However, what I don't need are prescriptions for making adjustments to my psyche and how to use that psyche to develop strategies to cope with my depressive illness. You don't have a clue.
>
> I'm sure your advice to me would be appropriate for some other people - just not me. For me, you were wrong.
>
> - ScottThere is a spectrum of the degree and variability to this disease. There are times that turning on the computer is as hard for me as what running a marathon is to someone else.
If you suggest that someone can simply ignore any disease with "mental powers", you have not experienced what it is like to be at the more difficult part of the spectrum - and no judgement should be made. Are we not trying to change the public's perception of mental illness - it can be a serious disease.
When people offer what they percieve as "advice" to those who are already especially sensitive and hard on themselves, to be very critical and demeaning.
Posted by alchemy on August 22, 2012, at 18:45:39
In reply to Re: Too bad we aren't well enough to be scientists » Tomatheus, posted by phidippus on August 22, 2012, at 15:37:22
> > Does this mean everybody, including the mentally >challenged and those with severe brain injuries?
>
> Stephen Hawking.
>
> People in comas? Yeah, I meant them too, f*ck*ng vegetables can wake up whenever they want.
>
> If a mentally challenged person hasn't gone to college its because they don't want to. Nothing is stopping them.
>
> John Nash
>
> In my eyes, the mentally challenged can do whatever they want. That means stay put or become mega porn stars, whatever.
>
> Beethoven
>
> EricEric,
I am feeling like your posts are attacking and very offensive. I may need to notify the board to block this discussion. I should not have started it.
Posted by Tomatheus on August 22, 2012, at 20:05:36
In reply to Re: Too bad we aren't well enough to be scientists » phidippus, posted by alchemy on August 22, 2012, at 18:45:39
> Eric,
> I am feeling like your posts are attacking and very offensive. I may need to notify the board to block this discussion. I should not have started it.Alchemy,
I liked the way this discussion started off with your original post and some of the posts that initially followed, and I'm sorry if I hijacked your thread with my reply to Eric/Phidippus. I probably shouldn't have escalated the situation with the post that I wrote. However, I think that you made some good comments in your original post, and I do hope that you can find a way to prepare for a career in medical research, whether or not you're ready to start taking the needed courses at this point in time.
Tomatheus
Posted by Phillipa on August 22, 2012, at 20:58:26
In reply to Re: Too bad we aren't well enough to be scientists » alchemy, posted by Tomatheus on August 22, 2012, at 20:05:36
I have found that to remain inactive is courting depression. I remember when a pdoc said to me as long as you remain anxious I know you are okay. Now I know what he meant as that is what keeps me moving. Yesterday rode 6 miles on bike in pouring rain as I refused to let something defeat like the weather. I was always called a survivor. I must be as no younger people were out in a yellow slicker getting drenched. A therapist once said you must leave the house daily and do something. I remember this board telling me for years to volunteer but I volunteerd before Nursing. So to me this would be going backward so now sell new items on Ebay with husband. Our source of income. Phillipa
Posted by phidippus on August 23, 2012, at 7:23:23
In reply to Re: Too bad we aren't well enough to be scientists » phidippus, posted by alchemy on August 22, 2012, at 18:45:39
You're right. I got defensive and went overboard. Please except my apologies.
Eric
Posted by Willful on August 23, 2012, at 17:22:38
In reply to Re: Too bad we aren't well enough to be scientists » alchemy, posted by phidippus on August 23, 2012, at 7:23:23
I didn't think Phillipus did anything so awful. Maybe s/he got defensive-- but Scott was being pretty accusatory.
Maybe no one else feels this, but for myself, but I don't so much like Scott's saying that he is so far below his intellectual level, when many people here have acknowledged him as very intellectually sophisticated and informed. Many people look to him for guidance and judgment, and I wonder if it doesn't reflect some depressive sense of perfectionism that he believes he has fallen so far below his level. And it is not kind to others who admire him so much.
The length of time it takes to write a sentence or paragraph isn't a measure of intellectual ability, or performance-- the content of the sentence is- Many people write slowly or revise over and over and over.
And many people don't have the intellectual fortitude to study and read pages of intellectual material under any circumstances.
I don't know Scott-- I don't know his level of achievement or his underlying ability, but I 'm not clear at all how he become so fixed on the idea that he has so underachieved compared to the potential that he has.
All of us-- have failed to achieve our dreams, and all of us are less that the self that we can imagine.
and I don't mean all of on Babble-- I mean all of us in the world.
Wilfull
Go forward in thread:
Psycho-Babble Medication | Extras | FAQ
Dr. Bob is Robert Hsiung, MD,
bob@dr-bob.org
Script revised: February 4, 2008
URL: http://www.dr-bob.org/cgi-bin/pb/mget.pl
Copyright 2006-17 Robert Hsiung.
Owned and operated by Dr. Bob LLC and not the University of Chicago.