![[dr. bob]](/dr-bob-sm.gif)
Dr. Bob is Robert Hsiung, MD,
bob@dr-bob.orgShown: posts 18 to 42 of 107. Go back in thread:
Posted by zeugma on January 28, 2005, at 14:52:36
In reply to Re: Treating side effects » zeugma, posted by ed_uk on January 28, 2005, at 14:29:45
don't really understand why your pdoc thought that it was ok to prescribe methylphenidate but won't let you try dextroamphetamine, I'm really not convinced that there is good logic behind this.>
I'm not either. But I don't know all the premises!
Do the cardiovascular side effects of MPH cause you a lot of anxiety? If they do, perhaps atenolol would reduce your anxiety. >well, they do, but I have a lot of anxiety anyway :( And I am convinced at this point that stimulants will be anxiogenic for me, and that is a real, intractable problem. Of course dexedrine may be less anxiogenic than Ritalin. That's important for me to keep in mind, depending on what happens with Strattera.
About Strat: yes, it made me tired and depressed last year. And this time we didn't even discuss why strattera was better for ADHD than desipramine. The truth is that I don't think he knows either. On paper it looks like Strattera is desipramine with a short half-life. If that's the case, then I am trying desipramine after all :) I know it won't energize me, but MAYBE i can take afternoon naps to compensate for the tiredness- if I can get the Klonopin down, that is, and get my plasma levels of nort back up, plus the Strattera. Klonopin worsens the sleep paralysis stuff, that's why I'm not crazy about trying more anxiogenic drugs that will require higher doses of K to control the anxiety.I can find no reason for thinking strattera is more effective than a TCA for ADD. I only know that it was, for me, once upon a time.
-z
Posted by zeugma on January 28, 2005, at 14:59:44
In reply to Re: Treating side effects » ed_uk, posted by zeugma on January 28, 2005, at 14:52:36
On 100 mg nortriptyline, I had no 'word-finding' difficulties, etc., or other cognitive problems other than the ones I was born with. When I lowered the dose of nortrip, I experienced these kinds of difficulties, and I think they were due to the sleep disruption the lowered dose was causing. I know antimuscarinics have a bad reputation, but it seems my cholinergic system is literally in overdrive and that's why I get blasted with cataplexy etc. every time I lower the dose of the 'dumb-drug'.
-z
Posted by ed_uk on January 28, 2005, at 15:28:13
In reply to Re: Treating side effects » ed_uk, posted by zeugma on January 28, 2005, at 14:52:36
Hi,
>On paper it looks like Strattera is desipramine with a short half-life.
It is possible that the problem with atomoxetine may be due to its active metabolite rather than the parent compound. Kappa agonists cause dysphoria and fatigue- which is why they never achieved popularity as analgesics!
I think it would be good for you to try...
clonazepam + dextroamphetamine IR + atenolol + nortriptyline 100mg
Ed.
Posted by zeugma on January 28, 2005, at 17:01:43
In reply to Re: Treating side effects » zeugma, posted by ed_uk on January 28, 2005, at 15:28:13
> Hi Ed.
Hi,
>
> >On paper it looks like Strattera is desipramine with a short half-life.
>
> It is possible that the problem with atomoxetine may be due to its active metabolite rather than the parent compound. Kappa agonists cause dysphoria and fatigue- which is why they never achieved popularity as analgesics!
>
Yes, that's what i theorized when I read the report about 4-hydroxyatomoxetine's partial kappa agonism. And it may well be that this theory is correct and dysphoria and fatigue will hit me again. But just like I didn't throw out my Strattera from last year, and was able to use it PRN when I was forced off provigil suddenly (I have a lot of problems with stimulants, you see) my pdoc told me I could use Ritalin on weekends when my extreme jitteriness wouldn't be a problem (my job involves a lot of interpersonal interaction and the jitteriness is a major liability). I would only do that, though, if my GP or my pdoc agreed to prescribe me atenolol. And, actually, I would prefer not to do it at all, considering that 60 mg seems to be the minimum to get an effect, and it doesn't last all that long.
> I think it would be good for you to try...
>
> clonazepam + dextroamphetamine IR + atenolol + nortriptyline 100mg
>Yes, I think that is a good combination. the clonazepam needs to be kept to a minimum, because it aggravates my cataplexy (taking 1.5 mg for the last couple of days has made me a nervous wreck because of this in itself- it's so complicated) but if d-amph is less anxiogenic and atenolol keeps the cardiac problems under control, then I will definitely propose this combo to my pdoc if I have to d/c Strattera again, because of fatigue or dysphoria, or simply because i can't get anyhthing done because of exhaustion. One way that narcoleptics who can't tolerate stimulants manage the sleepiness is by scheduling naps during the day. Once all this clonazepam is out of my system and I'm back down to a maintainance level (1 mg) and the nortriptyline increase has kicked in, then Strattera might be genuinely useful for naps because I could take it at noon and its powerful NRI effect would let me nap in peace. That's my current thinking, but I'll have to see how it works out. Right now there's so much clonazepam in my system that I can't nap at all.
-z
> Ed.
Posted by ed_uk on January 29, 2005, at 17:26:59
In reply to Re: Treating side effects » ed_uk, posted by zeugma on January 28, 2005, at 17:01:43
Hi Z!
Good luck with the Strattera :-)
Have you ever taken more than 100mg of nortriptyline? I wondered whether you'd find it helpful for anxiety or ADD symptoms.
Also, have you tried any other benzos apart from clonazepam? Do they all worsen your cataplexy?
How long did you take Strattera for before it made you fatigued and depressed? The kappa agonists used as analgesics generally cause dysphoria and sedation with the first dose. Mmmm, I wonder what else Strattera is doing apart from acting as an NRI? I've often wondered the same thing RE reboxetine.
Ed.
Posted by zeugma on January 29, 2005, at 19:42:24
In reply to Re: Treating side effects » zeugma, posted by ed_uk on January 29, 2005, at 17:26:59
>
> Good luck with the Strattera :-)thanks!
>
> Have you ever taken more than 100mg of nortriptyline? I wondered whether you'd find it helpful for anxiety or ADD symptoms.
>It might be helpful for anxiety and even ADD, I don't know. 100 mg nortrip seems to be more stimulating than 75 mg, but nothing like the effects of Provigil or ritalin.
> Also, have you tried any other benzos apart from clonazepam? Do they all worsen your cataplexy?
No, I haven't, it was hard enough to get the clonazepam! Doctors may be less leery of prescribing benzos in the US than UK, but only slightly. Alprazolam is seen as having a much higher abuse potential than clonazepam, so it's much harder to get prescribed. What is interesting about clonazepam is the fact that it's a powerful antiepileptic, and the fact that it triggers cataplexy made me realize that my sleep disorder was probably REM rather than NREM related. >
> How long did you take Strattera for before it made you fatigued and depressed? The kappa agonists used as analgesics generally cause dysphoria and sedation with the first dose. Mmmm, I wonder what else Strattera is doing apart from acting as an NRI? I've often wondered the same thing RE reboxetine.
>
it was quite a while. I was on strattera for nearly a year before the fatigue and depression became severe. strattera distinctly does NOT have a sedating or dysphoric effect on first dose, in fact it strikes me as a powerful antidepressant that is neutral as regards sedation. The depression and fatigue that later hit is another story, and my pdoc attributed it to the fact that I needed a stimulant, and my physical energy simply gave out. that's plausible, but leaves me where I started: the fatigue has been constant for years, and I have not been able to tolerate ANY stimulating medication (Wellbutrin, Ritalin, cylert, Provigil). I think this strongly negative history with stims caused him to skip the amphetamines. Part of the problem, as I see it, is that stims produce positive effects only when plasma levels are highest, and on the up- or down-slope I would experience severe irritability, anxiety, and marginal cognitive benefit. I don't see any way around this conundrum.
I wonder what your view of the effectiveness of reboxetine is. have you ever tried it? Like i said before, I really don't know the justification for adding strattera as opposed to simply increasing nortrip beyond 100 mg, except for the lack of cardiotoxicity. I even wonder if some of my response to strattera was placebo. I know people sometimes combine SSRI's, but that there is no evident justification for this, and psychopharmacological orthodoxy counsels against this kind of redundancy.Are you still trying to get on some kind of stimulant? I know you highly favor d-amphetamine over methylphenidate. Is this because d-amph is less anxiogenic?
-z
> Ed.
Posted by ed_uk on January 29, 2005, at 21:12:57
In reply to Re: Treating side effects » ed_uk, posted by zeugma on January 29, 2005, at 19:42:24
Hi,
>> Have you ever taken more than 100mg of nortriptyline?
>It might be helpful for anxiety and even ADD, I don't know. 100 mg nortrip seems to be more stimulating than 75 mg.Try it!
>Doctors may be less leery of prescribing benzos in the US than UK, but only slightly.
Don't be so sure! One thing I have noticed is that MUCH higher doses seem to be prescribed in the US, for much longer periods of time!
> Part of the problem, as I see it, is that stims produce positive effects only when plasma levels are highest, and on the up- or down-slope I would experience severe irritability, anxiety, and marginal cognitive benefit. I don't see any way around this conundrum.
I think you could probably overcome this by taking small dose very frequently (every couple of hours)- this would avoid any major peaks or troughs.
>I wonder what your view of the effectiveness of reboxetine is. have you ever tried it?
I've never tried it. Although Edronax is marketed here it's rarely prescribed to be honest. Do you want to try it?
>Are you still trying to get on some kind of stimulant?
Yes, but I doubt I'll ever get one though, I might as well be asking for IV heroin!
I know you highly favor d-amphetamine over methylphenidate. Is this because d-amph is less anxiogenic?
It would be interesting to see some scientific evidence that d-amph is less anxiogenic- there doesn't seem to be any, all the evidence I've got is anecdotal. If I had the opportunity to try any stim, I think I might actually try Ritalin first because of the evidence that high doses of d-amph *may* be neurotoxic in animals. I suspect that I'd end up on d-amph though, most adults seem to prefer it to Ritalin.
Ed.
Posted by zeugma on January 31, 2005, at 16:29:47
In reply to Re: Treating side effects » zeugma, posted by ed_uk on January 29, 2005, at 21:12:57
anyway, im done with strattera, it is triggering a severe depression again and my pdoc doesn't want to hear about it. i feel completely hopeless.
-z
Posted by ed_uk on February 1, 2005, at 8:22:16
In reply to Re: Treating side effects, posted by zeugma on January 31, 2005, at 16:29:47
Hello Z,
>anyway, im done with strattera, it is triggering a severe depression again and my pdoc doesn't want to hear about it. i feel completely hopeless.
What do you mean when you say that your pdoc doesn't want to hear about it?
Don't feel hopeless, you have options :-)
a) Dex + atenolol.
b) Desipramine instead of nort- could be more stimulating.
c) Parnate- may relieve hypersomnia and cataplexy too.
d) Try a higher dose of nortriptyline.
e) Maybe even Desoxyn + atenolol!
f) Get a new pdoc!
g) Go to a sleep specialist.Do you drink coffee or take caffeine tablets? Maybe caffeine tablets would be bettter because you could take a more precise dose.
All the best,
Ed.
Posted by zeugma on February 1, 2005, at 16:37:34
In reply to Re: Treating side effects » zeugma, posted by ed_uk on February 1, 2005, at 8:22:16
hi ed, I just bought a package of NoDoz at the pharmacy. I am breaking down rapidly and losing the ability to function. I called a sleep doc and am trying to make an appointment. My pdoc didn't want to hear about problems with Strattera because he is convinced of its unique efficacy, which I am unable to account for. But it has a fatiguing effect which I cannot tolerate. I know I have pharma options but at this time have no mental health professional whom I trust, abd I am in a debilitated state right now. Hopefully the sleep doc will get back to me and I can make an appt. ASAP.
-z
Posted by zeugma on February 1, 2005, at 16:45:06
In reply to Re: Treating side effects » ed_uk, posted by zeugma on February 1, 2005, at 16:37:34
and 'by didn't want to hear about it', brushed aside depressogenic and fatiguing effects (which i experienced last year to a severe degree) and told me to simply titrate slower (although I was following his instructions by taking 25 mg am 3 days, then 40 mg yesterday morning. the sample packs he gave me of 25's and 40's have only 7 capsules, while I still have a lot of 40's from my last trial with this drug, so I planned (with his OK) to start at 25, then go to 40, then take 40 am and 25 pm for a couple of days. When I called in a state of despair he told me I was titrating too fast and stay at 25 for a while. That's what I mean by 'brushing aside my concerns.' admittedly I am in a desperate state, I also am going through stim withdrawal, and Strat seemed to be making it worse. I don't know what else to say. Hopefully I can find another doctor soon.
-z
Posted by ed_uk on February 2, 2005, at 7:20:00
In reply to Re: Treating side effects » zeugma, posted by zeugma on February 1, 2005, at 16:45:06
Hello Z,
>I am breaking down rapidly and losing the ability to function.
Do you think that your current fatigue and depression may be mainly caused by methylphenidate withdrawal? As you know, stim withdrawal can easily cause both these symptoms even in people with no history of depression or narcolepsy.
>I called a sleep doc and am trying to make an appointment.
Excellent- I hope s/he can see you quickly.
> know I have pharma options but at this time have no mental health professional whom I trust, abd I am in a debilitated state right now.
You do trust your current pdoc though, don't you? He may not be the best but I thought you still trusted him.
Can you take some time off work???
Best Regards,
Ed.
Posted by zeugma on February 2, 2005, at 15:51:05
In reply to Re: Stimulant withdrawal » zeugma, posted by ed_uk on February 2, 2005, at 7:20:00
> Hello Z,
>
> >I am breaking down rapidly and losing the ability to function.
>
> Do you think that your current fatigue and depression may be mainly caused by methylphenidate withdrawal? As you know, stim withdrawal can easily cause both these symptoms even in people with no history of depression or narcolepsy.
>
Hi Ed. yes I know, and it's nasty withdrawal, absolutely brutal to go from 60 mg to 0 with no taper. I essentially had no choice, because the stim itslef was interfering with my ability to work by causing extreme nervousness, irritability, etc., as well as physically wasting me away. I realized also that when the MPH was withdrawn, I had put the nortriptyline back to 75 from 50 mg as the cardiac interaction with MPH was no longer a danger. This was done with pdoc's consent, of course. THEN adding the Strattera onto that was putting my brain through so many changes at once that I think I was literally overwhelmed. Nortriptyline's effects are very dose dependent-I am apt to forget this as it is actually the most well-tolerated, over a wide dose range, psychotropic I have ever taken. I suppose I've adjusted the nortrip so many times that it seemed like nothing to put it back at 75 mg. Well, actually, I think a lot of the reason the Ritalin went bad was because of the nortrip going down to a sub-therapeutic dose. I am definitely feeling the effects of the 75 mg nortrip today, a definite antidepressant effect.yes, I still trust him, though whether he trusts me is an open question. I don't know about the strattera. Thinking now, I realize that just raising the NOR and going cold turkey off the MPH was in itself an enormous med change, the likes of which I've never experienced.
> >I called a sleep doc and am trying to make an appointment.
>
> Excellent- I hope s/he can see you quickly.Yes, but sleep clinics are enormously expensive. I am going to have to have a sleep study done, and it runs into the thousands of dollars. And I assume I will have to wash out my meds. I am in touch with one clinician and trying to work out a feasible way to proceed. At this point the sooner the better, so I will know by tomorrow which clinician I will see and what kind of washout it will entail.
>
> > know I have pharma options but at this time have no mental health professional whom I trust, abd I am in a debilitated state right now.
>
> You do trust your current pdoc though, don't you? He may not be the best but I thought you still trusted him.see above, I do, though I admit I am puzzled by his high regard for Strattera. As far as I am concerned nortriptyline is a far more trustworthy med.
>
> Can you take some time off work???
>I took some days off last week when I was literally flattened by stim withdrawal (yes, I'm speaking literally). And then going up 25 mg on nortrip plus 25 mg strattera- well, that's crazy. Though I don't fault my pdoc for this. His decision to pull the plug on the MPH was the correct one, and he advised me to take the rest of the week off, as he told me I wouldn't be feeling too great. Understatement of the millenium :)
> Best Regards,
> Ed.
>
In case you are interested, I have some info on Strat's pharmacology:Atomoxetine Ki values:
Ne transporter: 4.5 nM
5HT transporter: 152 nM
DA transporter: 1451 nM4-hydroxyatomoxetine:
NE transporter: 3.0 nM
5HT tranporter: 43 nM
kappa opiod receptor: 95 nM
mu, delta receptors: > or = 422 nM.Apparently, in extensive metabolizers 4-hydroxy plasma levels are higher than parent drug, and its half-life is 6-8 vs. 5 hrs. What do you think of this pharmacology? Thanks for all your support,
z
>
>
>
Posted by reefer on February 3, 2005, at 5:33:48
In reply to Re: Treating side effects » zeugma, posted by ed_uk on January 28, 2005, at 15:28:13
Oh that's why Buprenorphine works so good for me. Since it is a Kappa antagonist. I never really understood why Bupe didn't make me sedated like the other opiods do.
Posted by ed_uk on February 3, 2005, at 8:29:41
In reply to Re: Stimulant withdrawal » ed_uk, posted by zeugma on February 2, 2005, at 15:51:05
Hi Z!
I'm relieved that you're feeling a bit better today :-)
>Nortriptyline's effects are very dose dependent-I am apt to forget this as it is actually the most well-tolerated, over a wide dose range, psychotropic I have ever taken.
I wonder what dose of nortriptyline would be the most effective for you? Some people need up to 150mg. Have you ever had your serum level measured? Of course, the only way to truly find the optimum dose is to experiment!
> Well, actually, I think a lot of the reason the Ritalin went bad was because of the nortrip going down to a sub-therapeutic dose.
Perhaps if you were on a full dose of nort you could tolerate the Ritalin. I'm sure you'd need to combine it with a suitable cardiovascular drug. I wonder what suggestions a cardiologist might have.
>I will know by tomorrow which clinician I will see and what kind of washout it will entail.
Good luck :-) Keep me updated.
>kappa opiod receptor: 95 nM
I'm sorry, I'm not sure whether 95 is low enough to be significant.
>Thanks for all your support
It's a pleasure!
Ed.
Posted by CareBear04 on February 3, 2005, at 13:18:59
In reply to Re: Stimulant withdrawal » ed_uk, posted by zeugma on February 2, 2005, at 15:51:05
zeugma-- i hope you're feeling better! i think i remember reading in your posts awhile ago that you have problems eating on stimulants and that you've been experimenting to try to find one that doesn't speed you up too much? is that accurate or am i mixing you up with someone else?
what i've experienced and heard about strattera from my later pdoc is that it tends to work best for children and less well for adults. it didn't do much of anything for me. i went up to 80mg a day in split doses, then added provigil. i liked the provigil and it definitely helped me focus without ruining my sleep. however, with provigil and strattera together, i could take the strattera or not and couldn't feel any difference. have you tried provigil? it did make me a bit of a zombie as far as repetetive tasks or doing one thing for hours on end when i was alone in my dorm room. a good thing is that it suppressed my appetite, but when i made myself remember to eat, even setting alarms if necessary, i had no problem with working up an appetite to eat.
about your sleep-- do you think it's related to your meds or psych condition or related to a pulmonary problem? my sister is a few months from graduating from med school, and i actually had a conversation with her about sleep medicine yesterday. i was surprised when i learned recently that most sleep doctors are pulmonary specialists and not pdocs like i had previously thought. i guess the "true" sleep disorders originate in the lungs and breathing, while insomnia and restlessness of a psychiatric or medicine origin are best dealt with in therapy or with a pdoc. i don't know if this is relevant or not.
going from 60 to 0 cold turkey from any stim sounds like torture to me. i know that i should take vacations from my adderall and ritalin to make it more effective because i've worked up quite a tolerance to them. but the thought of being off them, being so sluggish and cranky, scares me and prevents me from taking even weekend breaks. how are you doing with this?
what other stims have you tried and what experiences have you had? i've tried high-dose wellbutrin, strattera, provigil, regular adderall and xr, regular ritalin and concerta. i once asked about focalin, but hardly any pharmacies around me carry it or can even order it for some reason. my pdoc had never heard of it either. i don't know what other options are. some people mentioned tricyclics to augment, but my drs won't prescribe them because of some heart abnormalities.
i'd like to hear more about your experience if you get a chance. thanks!
Posted by zeugma on February 3, 2005, at 17:06:18
In reply to Re: Stimulant withdrawal » zeugma, posted by ed_uk on February 3, 2005, at 8:29:41
hi Ed, just to let you know, I've been feeling better now that the nortriptyline has kicked in again. I've had this experience before: going below 75 mg plunges me into misery.
My blood levels were taken a couple of years ago when I was on 60 mg nortrip and experiencing a suboptimal response. My pdoc didn't tell me the exact level but said it was 'low' so I moved up to 75 mg and started feeling better. So I'm assuming 75 mg is the bottom threshold for therapeutic response.
I suppose I'll try 25 mg Strattera again tomorrow. I don't know if my current pdoc will see me any more, though. I didn't call the sleep doctor today but will have more time tomorrow (less full work schedule).
It's been really, really crazy lately with all the med changes and trying desperately to hang on to my job. I suppose I need to get used to the anxiety, or think about something like Seroquel. I just worry about movement disorders (I have a tic from the Ritalin) and I experienced a neuroleptic-like effect from >30 mg buspirone, and buspirone is a very weak D2 antagonist.
So yes, I'm feeling better, but I don't know if I currently have a pdoc, because the way I left it with him was that I would see a sleep doc instead. (I'm putting it mildly, of course. I was yelling at him on the phone, and this is not very cool behavior. this is part of why the Ritalin had such a bad effect on me. Instead of calming me down as is apparently the norm with ADHD patients it hyped me up.)
-z
Posted by zeugma on February 3, 2005, at 17:12:07
In reply to Re: Stimulant withdrawal » zeugma, posted by CareBear04 on February 3, 2005, at 13:18:59
hi carebear. I've tried wellbutrin, provigil, cylert, ritalin. I can't take any of them.
The Provigil was actually the best from the appetite point of view because I actually only lost a pound on it after a couple of months on it. It also seemed to be the opposite of Ritalin in that it slowed down my thought process and was anxiolytic, which were VERY good things. but unfortunately the sweating, feeling simultaneously hot and cold, queasy, and generally sick made it impossible for me to stick it out.
Right now I'm relying on caffeine pills to keep me alert. I suppose I've imbibed so much caffeine over the years that I've built up a tolerance to its anxiogenicity.
-z
Posted by CareBear04 on February 3, 2005, at 19:36:55
In reply to Re: Stimulant withdrawal » CareBear04, posted by zeugma on February 3, 2005, at 17:12:07
hey zeugma, i hear you on the caffeine. last year, i went for about a month and a half without any caffeine, and when i had coffee ice cream at the end of that time, i couldn't sleep all night! that was before i was on prescription stimulants. i also drink a lot of coffee. i think the tolerance to caffeine plus the heavy duty prescription stims have caused me to be immune to caffeine. i used to take the caffeine pills a few years ago, and i could take, like, 4 or more and fall asleep right away with all that in my stomach. i think it caused some ulceration.
i think the provigil slowed my thoughts down, too. adderall and ritalin calm me down, too, but in a different way. provigil slowed me down enough that i could sit in the same position forever and focus on one thing. but like you, it was pretty weight neutral as long as i remembered to eat.
do you know if caffeine has the same side effects as the schedule II stims? high blood pressure and pulse, headaches, strokes and heart attacks in overdose? also, do you know if your weight loss on stims is due to suppression of your appetite or possibly the speeding up of your metabolism? mostly, i hear about their killing appetite, but i think i read once about amphetamines speeding everything up, including metabolism. maybe when the heart works harder and beats faster, you need more fuel to feed the process? have your docs every talked about anything like this?
hope you're well.
Posted by ed_uk on February 4, 2005, at 6:29:47
In reply to Re: Stimulant withdrawal, posted by zeugma on February 3, 2005, at 17:06:18
Hi Z!
Glad to hear you're feeling better :-) I hope the Strattera helps. If not, will you try 100mg nort?
>I suppose I need to get used to the anxiety, or think about something like Seroquel. I just worry about movement disorders (I have a tic from the Ritalin) and I experienced a neuroleptic-like effect from >30 mg buspirone, and buspirone is a very weak D2 antagonist.
Seroquel *might* reduce your anxiety but on the other hand it might just knock you out! Perhaps a small dose in the evening would be enough. What happened when you took buspirone?
>I was yelling at him on the phone, and this is not very cool behavior.
He's probably used to being shouted at! Call him, I'm sure he'll understand :-)
>Instead of calming me down as is apparently the norm with ADHD patients it hyped me up.
It often hypes up ADHD patients as well!
Ed.
Posted by zeugma on February 4, 2005, at 19:22:37
In reply to Re: Stimulants » zeugma, posted by ed_uk on February 4, 2005, at 6:29:47
> Hi Z!
>
> Glad to hear you're feeling better :-) I hope the Strattera helps. If not, will you try 100mg nort?Of course. My script is for 100 mg. 100 mg worked fine until I had the Ritalin problem.
>
> >I suppose I need to get used to the anxiety, or think about something like Seroquel. I just worry about movement disorders (I have a tic from the Ritalin) and I experienced a neuroleptic-like effect from >30 mg buspirone, and buspirone is a very weak D2 antagonist.
>
> Seroquel *might* reduce your anxiety but on the other hand it might just knock you out! Perhaps a small dose in the evening would be enough. What happened when you took buspirone?
>
I felt *knocked out*! Severely. I felt like I did on Trialfon, an old typical AP- seriously wiped out, and I wasn't exactly a ball of energy to begin with. That was every time I went over 30 mg buspirone. At that dose or lower, no probs. I take 15 mg at night to help me with the hypnagogic hallucinations. It has an anti-cataplectic action, and is absorbed much faster than nortriptyline. it is also an AD, though maybe a weak one- but I'll take all the mood elevation I can get.
> >I was yelling at him on the phone, and this is not very cool behavior.
>
> He's probably used to being shouted at! Call him, I'm sure he'll understand :-)
>
Ah, he's understood before, if you know what I mean. I fear I am a difficult patient.
> >Instead of calming me down as is apparently the norm with ADHD patients it hyped me up.
>
> It often hypes up ADHD patients as well!
>I suppose that famous 'paradoxical' calming effect isn't all it's cracked up to be, then? Yet another urban folktale circulating in the realm of psych disorders :-)
By the way, how are you doing off the TCA?
-z
-z
> Ed.
Posted by ed_uk on February 5, 2005, at 10:44:08
In reply to Re: Stimulants » ed_uk, posted by zeugma on February 4, 2005, at 19:22:37
Hi Z!
>I suppose that famous 'paradoxical' calming effect isn't all it's cracked up to be, then?
I think this is something that often causes confusion! When parents say that Ritalin 'calms' their child they generally mean that it reduces hyperactivity ie. not that it 'calms' anxiety. As you know all too well, Ritalin often makes anxiety worse- although a few people do seem to find it anxiolytic. The fact that it can reduce hyperactivity is not really paradoxical at all! Because Ritalin often makes boring repetitive tasks seem interesting, and because it generally improves concentration, Ritalin can often reduce boredom and 'fidgety restlessness', even on people who have not been diagnosed with ADHD. This effect is certainly not unique to children ...nor is it unique to ADHD patients, as has often been claimed. Because Ritalin is commonly refered to as a stimulant, people find it very hard to understand how it can reduce hyperactivity. Perhaps it would be better just to refer to it as methylphenidate! Because it called a stimulant, people often think that it effects will be the opposite of a sedative such as Xanax. Pharmacologically, the effects of Ritalin are in no way 'opposite' to the effects of Xanax. Classifying drugs as being either stimulants or sedatives is really very crude!! After all, some people get hyped-up on benzos!
Whether or not Ritalin makes a person 'hyper' is very individual, it is not simply a function of their age or whether or not they have been diagnosed with ADHD. Some ADHD children get much worse on Ritalin, whereas other improve greatly. This also applies to ADHD adults. Similarly, some non-ADHD adults get very 'hyped-up' on Ritalin, whereas others find that it helps them sit still and complete masses of paperwork. As ever, drug response is very individual... and very difficult to predict. Response to Ritalin also depends on dose, most people would feel hyped-up if they took too much. The doses which are effective for hyperactive children are generally quite low. There is so much trial and error in psycho-pharmacology, much more that most pdocs would be willing to admit!
Ed.
Posted by ed_uk on February 5, 2005, at 10:46:42
In reply to Re: Stimulants » ed_uk, posted by zeugma on February 4, 2005, at 19:22:37
PS. Sorry about the rant!!! I got a bit carried away!!
I restarted the lofepramine last week. I think I felt a bit more fatigued without it, it might have just been a withdrawal symptom though- or perhaps it was a figment of my imagination.
I'm really pleased that you're feeling a bit better :-D
Ed.
Posted by CareBear04 on February 5, 2005, at 12:47:48
In reply to Re: Stimulants » zeugma, posted by ed_uk on February 5, 2005, at 10:44:08
ed-- thanks for the info.
here's a question i've wondered about-- my friend who has a little brother with ADHD talked about how he went in for teeth extraction or something. they tried to give him sedatives, but he kept getting more and more hyped up. accoreding to this friend, sedatives have the opposite effect on ADD kids. is this true?
for me, benzos make me calm; stimulants maybe a bit calmer.
Posted by ed_uk on February 5, 2005, at 13:46:31
In reply to Re: Stimulants » ed_uk, posted by CareBear04 on February 5, 2005, at 12:47:48
Hi,
>but he kept getting more and more hyped up. accoreding to this friend, sedatives have the opposite effect on ADD kids. is this true?
Sedatives such as benzodiazepines do sometimes increase hyperactivity in children with ADHD. This is not inevitable though, and they can still be effective in reducing anxiety. In general, unusual reactions to sedatives seem to be significantly more common in children than in adults.
Ed.
Go forward in thread:
Psycho-Babble Medication | Extras | FAQ
Dr. Bob is Robert Hsiung, MD,
bob@dr-bob.org
Script revised: February 4, 2008
URL: http://www.dr-bob.org/cgi-bin/pb/mget.pl
Copyright 2006-17 Robert Hsiung.
Owned and operated by Dr. Bob LLC and not the University of Chicago.