Psycho-Babble Social | for general support | Framed
This thread | Show all | Post follow-up | Start new thread | List of forums | Search | FAQ

Re: Depends on the accuracy of the kindling theory » Ritch

Posted by Randal on August 22, 2002, at 15:07:30

In reply to Re: Depends on the accuracy of the kindling theory... » Randal, posted by Ritch on August 20, 2002, at 23:40:31

Mitch,

Very good points. The ethics and legality of all this would get complicated. A 30 year-old woman *at risk* for breast cancer certainly can do something as radical as get a double mastectomy, or perhaps less extreme like take Tamoxifen. Can parents do something like give drugs to their kid in the absence of symptoms? I honestly don't know. (I'm sure the "right" doctor could somehow find symptoms in just about any kid though...).

Wouldn't vaccines be similar in concept to a medicating a kid who is at risk of a disease but doesn't in fact have it? Beyond the usual childhood vaccinations, I once got a shot of gamma globulin when a roomate came down with hepatitis. A kid exposed to Anthrax would certainly go on antibiotics even in the absence of symptoms. Are these really that different than giving medication to a kid likely to get bipolar? I'm trying to think of other examples--there must be some.

Regarding environmental vs. pharmacological prevention. Say, hypothetically, that it is found that sleep cycle, caffeine and alcohol intake are the most important environmental factors in triggering the disease. Are you sure these sorts of things can be controlled? What if something else comes in to play? It seems to me like you might be shooting at a moving target here.

Isn't Dilantin one of the old AEDs (anti-epileptic drugs) with the worst side effects? I would assume there are second and third-generation AEDs that have fewer side effects. And I'm *guessing* you wouldn't have to take them at the full dose needed for epilepsy.

You know, if the current studies pan out, maybe omega-3 fatty acids (in the large doses people use for bipolar) would be the "drug" of choice to prevent the disease. I think a lot of parents already do this. If I were in that position, even with the preliminary results out there on fish oil I would probably try this. It might be hard to get the kid to take the smelly pills, though! Gerber omega-3 fish mush??

Randal

> Randal,
>
> Interesting ideas. The first thing you would have to consider is whether or not the parents' bipolar disorder is being controlled or not and whether the parents are themselves taking medication to prevent relapses. If they are non-compliant, should the state have the *right* to intervene to "save their children" with antimanic medications? I think that would fall apart in court, big time. If their parents ARE compliant with their meds and seek a psychiatrist to prescribe prophylactic antimanic medication in the absence of any bipolar symptoms in their child, that psychiatrist could risk a big future lawsuit (not to mention possible ethical conflict in the doctor), so I think that scenario fails legally as well. EVEN if a genetic test were readily available that would show that 75% likelihood, it would still be on shaky legal grounds to prescribe (and especially enforce) medications in absence of any clinical *symptoms*. My conservative idea on the whole issue would be for compliant, knowledgeable bipolar parents to identify the *non-medication* approaches that could be helpful in preventing or delaying the onset of bipolar symptoms in their children regardless of positive genetics in the absence of any current clinical symptoms. Anticonvulsant medications are NOT innocuous substances. My mother had severe nocturnal generalized seizures for many years. She was on 400mg of Dilantin every day for about 20 years. She lost all of her teeth before she was 30 because of the Dilantin. However, many children suffer *life-threatening* seizures that require control with anticonvulsants. I would not want to treat anybody(if I was a doctor) with antimanic meds in absence of any clinical symptoms.
>
> Mitch
>
> > Hi Mitch,
> >
> > A related question:
> >
> > Say two bipolar parents have a kid. Statistically the chance of having a bipolar kid is 75% according to the Time article. This is even greater than for twins, and you would know this from birth, even without some sort of genetic test. The genetic test of course doesn't yet exist, but this is a scenario that must be faced now by a significant number of parents. Bipolar people are more likely to marry other bipolar people-- I think they called it assortive mating.
> >
> > Now should the parents give the kid low doses of some mood stabilizer (lithium, depakote, whatever) in the hopes of keeping the disease from ever surfacing? I mean even in the absence of any (clear) symptoms. Would this work?? My *guess* is that it's got to have some effect on at least slowing the progress of the disease. I might worry about giving a kid such drugs from early on and the possible dangers. However these must be known (and I assume they are not a big problem) since so many epileptic kids receive large doses of anti epileptic drugs throughout childhood.
> >
> > I guess a related question is whether epileptic kids, treated with such drugs throughout childhood, have a lower than expected rate of bipolar disorder. I understand that epileptics as a whole have a higher rate of bipolar disorder than the general population, so of course this would have to be factored in.
> >
> > More dramatic things have been done for other diseases. I'm thinking about breast cancer, where women with the gene have actually had mastectomies as a preventative measure. Bipolar disorder is also a life-threatening disease, with up to a 20% lifetime fatality rate from suicide.
> >
> > If I were such a parent I would want to do something like this. Does anyone know if people in fact do?
> >
> > Just thought I would throw this out to see if anyone else had any thoughts or experiences with this.
> >
> > Randal
>
>


Share
Tweet  

Thread

 

Post a new follow-up

Your message only Include above post


Notify the administrators

They will then review this post with the posting guidelines in mind.

To contact them about something other than this post, please use this form instead.

 

Start a new thread

 
Google
dr-bob.org www
Search options and examples
[amazon] for
in

This thread | Show all | Post follow-up | Start new thread | FAQ
Psycho-Babble Social | Framed

poster:Randal thread:28868
URL: http://www.dr-bob.org/babble/social/20020820/msgs/29069.html